I'm just back from bank holiday break and hope to find some time somewhere to blog some items of interest before heading off for the British New Testament Conference on Thursday. Here are the latest additions to the SBL Review of Biblical Literature under the New Testament heading:
Barr, David L.
Reading the Book of Revelation: A Resource for Students
Reviewed by Mark Bredin
Garland, David E.
1 Corinthians
Reviewed by Garwood Anderson
Haacker, Klaus
The Theology of Paul's Letter to the Romans
Reviewed by Daniel Kirk
Lohse, Eduard
Der Brief an die Römer
Reviewed by Marco Frenschkowski
Resseguie, James L.
Spiritual Landscape: Images of the Spiritual Life in the Gospel of Luke
Reviewed by Ronald R. Clark
Winter, Bruce W.
Roman Wives, Roman Widows: The Appearance of New Women and the Pauline Communities
Reviewed by Jennifer Knust
Tuesday, August 31, 2004
Friday, August 27, 2004
Aramaic gets boost from Hollywood
A short piece that may be of interest from this week's Church Times:
Aramaic gets boost from Hollywood
By Bill Bowder
Aramaic gets boost from Hollywood
By Bill Bowder
THE USE of Aramaic in Mel Gibson’s film The Passion of the Christ has led to a surge of interest in the language, which was spoken by Jesus and his disciples.And have a look at the cartoon.
The Metropolitan of the Chaldean Syrian Church of the East (the Syriac Church) in India, Dr Mar Aprem, has offered a beginners’ course in his diocese of Trichur in response to the sudden enthusiasm for the ancient language . . .
. . . . Mar Aprem’s enthusiasm for Mel Gibson’s film developed when he went with some of his clergy to see the film in Easter Week, the first time he had been to a cinema in 50 years, he said on Monday.
"The film has done good. They see how much Jesus suffered," he said. "After the film, people wanted to know more. I have asked two of my clergy to conduct a beginners’ course in Aramaic at the ecumenical research institute in Trichur. When I get back, I will also offer a master-class in Aramaic for those who have already been studying it."
Thursday, August 26, 2004
Passion of the Christ DVD Release
Some thoughts on the forthcoming Passion of the Christ DVD release, which must be selling at an extraordinary rate since it's already at number 2 in Amazon.com's list. This review at DVD Answers is by Richard Schuchardt and it includes some very favourable comments on the technical side, though it also wonders about the release having no extra features:
The Passion of the Christ
A 'Passion' for title tie-ins
By Thomas K. Arnold
I am a bit puzzled by this article's announcement of a DVD release for The Greatest Story Ever Told, though, since there was a major DVD release for this back in 2001 in a restored version with special features. I had a look to see if I could find anything on this new release on the web and I cannot, though I did come across an interesting piece on the release of that restored version over three years ago:
Restoring The Greatest Story Ever Told
Millimeter, March 1, 2001
The Passion of the Christ
The Passion of the Christ is presented in 2.35:1 anamorphic widescreen and there is very little more to say on the subject. Simply put, this transfer is outstanding and had no flaws that I noticed. The image is full of detail and brings the haunting death of Christ to the screen with amazing accuracy. Colours are true and vivid while the blacks were solid. I did notice a little bit of grain during some of the darker scenes but the grain levels never proved to be distracting. Due to the lack of extras this transfer doesn't suffer from compression artefacts, and edge enhancements were nowhere to be seen. Overall this is a top class transfer which no doubt benefits from the decision to keep this release free of extras. In some ways this transfer is what you would expect from a Superbits title . . . .An article in USA Today looks at the attempts to cash-in on the release:
. . . . It is becoming a rarity these days for high profile DVD releases to be barebones releases. More often than not most titles are released as two disc packages, so it was a big surprise when MGM announced that The Passion of the Christ was being released with no extras. The reason for this is still not clear, but it has been suggested that Mel wanted this release to focus on the movie only. As can be seen below the transfer and soundtracks benefit from the additional space. The more cynical among you will say that this release is a money making exercise in preparation for the expected special edition release next year. Either way, this release comes with no extras and only time will tell if we are to see a special edition release.
A 'Passion' for title tie-ins
By Thomas K. Arnold
I am a bit puzzled by this article's announcement of a DVD release for The Greatest Story Ever Told, though, since there was a major DVD release for this back in 2001 in a restored version with special features. I had a look to see if I could find anything on this new release on the web and I cannot, though I did come across an interesting piece on the release of that restored version over three years ago:
Restoring The Greatest Story Ever Told
Millimeter, March 1, 2001
BMCR Review of MacDonald on Homer and Acts
On b-greek, Maurice A. O'Sullivan notes the following review in Bryn Mawr Classical Review 2004.08.13:
Dennis R. MacDonald, Does the New Testament Imitate Homer? Four Cases from the Acts of the Apostles (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003)
Review by Manfred Lang
Dennis R. MacDonald, Does the New Testament Imitate Homer? Four Cases from the Acts of the Apostles (New Haven: Yale University Press, 2003)
Review by Manfred Lang
Wednesday, August 25, 2004
Review of Bibical Literature latest
These are the latest additions to the SBL Review of Biblical Literature under the New Testament heading:
Balch, David L. and Carolyn Osiek, eds.
Early Christian Families in Context: An Interdisciplinary Dialogue
Reviewed by Timothy Gombis
Balch, David L. and Carolyn Osiek, eds.
Early Christian Families in Context: An Interdisciplinary Dialogue
Reviewed by Tobias Nicklas
Barrett, C. K.
On Paul: Essays on His Life, Work and Influence in the Early Church
Reviewed by Eckhard J Schnabel
Best, Ernest
Ephesians: A Shorter Commentary
Reviewed by Timothy Gombis
Gillman, Florence Morgan
Herodias: At Home in That Fox's Den
Reviewed by Eric Noffke
Matthews, Shelly, Melanie Johnson-DeBaufre, and Cynthia Briggs Kittredge,
eds.
Walk in the Ways of Wisdom: Essays in Honor of Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza
Reviewed by Donna Wallace
Roetzel, Calvin J.
Paul: A Jew on the Margins
Reviewed by Fred Rich
van Aarde, Andries
Fatherless in Galilee: Jesus as Child of God
Reviewed by Alicia Batten
Balch, David L. and Carolyn Osiek, eds.
Early Christian Families in Context: An Interdisciplinary Dialogue
Reviewed by Timothy Gombis
Balch, David L. and Carolyn Osiek, eds.
Early Christian Families in Context: An Interdisciplinary Dialogue
Reviewed by Tobias Nicklas
Barrett, C. K.
On Paul: Essays on His Life, Work and Influence in the Early Church
Reviewed by Eckhard J Schnabel
Best, Ernest
Ephesians: A Shorter Commentary
Reviewed by Timothy Gombis
Gillman, Florence Morgan
Herodias: At Home in That Fox's Den
Reviewed by Eric Noffke
Matthews, Shelly, Melanie Johnson-DeBaufre, and Cynthia Briggs Kittredge,
eds.
Walk in the Ways of Wisdom: Essays in Honor of Elisabeth Schüssler Fiorenza
Reviewed by Donna Wallace
Roetzel, Calvin J.
Paul: A Jew on the Margins
Reviewed by Fred Rich
van Aarde, Andries
Fatherless in Galilee: Jesus as Child of God
Reviewed by Alicia Batten
Herod the Great @ Ancient / Classical History
In her Ancient / Classical History blog, N. S. Gill flags up this useful entry of hers on Herod the Great:
Herod the Great (73-4 B.C.)
Herod the Great (73-4 B.C.)
James Ossuary Update @ Hypotyposeis
Don't miss Stephen Carlson's comments on the latest updates on the James Ossuary in Biblical Archaeological Review, in particular his drawing attention to the report of a lecture by Oded Golan:
Update -- Finds or Fakes?
There is one interesting fact that came out of Golan's remarks: I learned that Golan's mother was "a professor of microbiology in Rehovot." This fact, however, makes his story somewhat more difficult to believe that his mother was responsible for accidentally depositing the fake patina when cleaning the ossuary. What scientist goes around a son's antiquities collection destroying evidence?Good point. It is perhaps worth adding that the Updates on the James Ossuary (and other controversial finds) is the one section of BAR that is still available on-line:
Update -- Finds or Fakes?
Marketing of The Passion of the Christ DVD
Thanks to David Mackinder for a link to the following story in today's New York Times today:
Pitching 'The Passion' DVD to Faithful Flocks
By LAURA M. HOLSON
On a related topic, I received my copy of Perspectives on the Passion of the Christ yesterday (see blog entry on). I'll post comments in due course, once I've caught up with correspondence, but so far I'm pretty disappointed -- there are repeated generalized surveys on the Gospel Passion narratives and the history of Christian anti-Semitism and so far, at least, no in depth critical engagement with the film at all.
Pitching 'The Passion' DVD to Faithful Flocks
By LAURA M. HOLSON
Orders for DVD's and videos are 20 percent ahead of projections, Fox executives said. Other Hollywood executives said that Fox might be shipping more than 15 million copies to retailers, a volume indicating that the studio believes the film could become one of the few R-rated movies to join the ranks of the 10 top-selling DVD's.It has reminded me to order my own copy. I've gone for Amazon.co.uk since the NT Gateway can take a small percentage of the order (to pay for the domain name and server).
"It's kind of an eclectic piece people will want in their collections," said Judith McCourt, director of research at Video Store Magazine, which tracks home-video sales. "This is going to be, in some vein, as popular a movie as 'Finding Nemo,' which had long sales legs. We are going to see that kind of selling power."
On a related topic, I received my copy of Perspectives on the Passion of the Christ yesterday (see blog entry on). I'll post comments in due course, once I've caught up with correspondence, but so far I'm pretty disappointed -- there are repeated generalized surveys on the Gospel Passion narratives and the history of Christian anti-Semitism and so far, at least, no in depth critical engagement with the film at all.
Monday, August 23, 2004
BNTC Seminar Programme
The full seminar programme for this year's British New Testament Conference in Edinburgh is now available on-line:
British New Testament Conference 2004 Seminar Programme
Update (16.20): Several papers are available on-line temporarily for delegates to download, currently in the Acts and Hermeneutics seminars, and in Jesus one of particular interest to me, Michael Goulder's Response to N. T. Wright on the Resurrection.
British New Testament Conference 2004 Seminar Programme
Update (16.20): Several papers are available on-line temporarily for delegates to download, currently in the Acts and Hermeneutics seminars, and in Jesus one of particular interest to me, Michael Goulder's Response to N. T. Wright on the Resurrection.
Walter Schmithals on The Passion
On Biblical Theology Jim West refers to a piece on The Passion of the Christ by Walter Schmithals. It is from Die Zeit and dates back to March, but I missed it at the time:
Gewaltverherrlichung ist der Bibel fremd
Den Evangelisten ging es nicht um Jesu Qualen, sondern darum, dass er für die Sünden der Menschen gestorben ist. Davon weiß Mel Gibsons Film „Die Passion Christi“ nichts
Von Walter Schmithals
The article consists primarily of working through the Gospel Passion Narratives and contrasting their approach with Gibson's. His essential complaint is that Gibson's film dwells so much on the blood and the agony of Jesus' crucifixion that it does not have time to invest in the theological, christological and soteriological meaning of Jesus' death that is the key concern of the New Testament writers:
Second, as I have often commented in the past, the idea that The Passion of the Christ falls short on the atonement is a fallacy. The film strives hard to set Jesus' death as a triumphant eschatological, salvation event in which sin is defeated and Satan is cast into hell (on more of which, see my article in the forthcoming Corley / Webb volume, on which I will be commenting in due course).
Gewaltverherrlichung ist der Bibel fremd
Den Evangelisten ging es nicht um Jesu Qualen, sondern darum, dass er für die Sünden der Menschen gestorben ist. Davon weiß Mel Gibsons Film „Die Passion Christi“ nichts
Von Walter Schmithals
The article consists primarily of working through the Gospel Passion Narratives and contrasting their approach with Gibson's. His essential complaint is that Gibson's film dwells so much on the blood and the agony of Jesus' crucifixion that it does not have time to invest in the theological, christological and soteriological meaning of Jesus' death that is the key concern of the New Testament writers:
Aber bei allen diesen unterschiedlichen Erzählstrategien der Evangelisten spielt die besondere Qual des Leidens und Sterbens Jesu am Kreuz ersichtlich keine Rolle. Da die Kreuzesstrafe häufig verhängt und immer öffentlich vollzogen wurde, setzen die Evangelisten bei ihren Lesern mit Recht eine Kenntnis des Strafvollzuges voraus und sehen davon ab, diesem Umstand besondere Aufmerksamkeit zu widmen.But I think Schmithals is missing a couple of important points. First, it is arguable that the evangelists do not need to dwell on the blood and the gore in the way that the contemporary does because the very words "they crucified Jesus" conjur up a wealth of appalling images to the ancient mind in the way that they do not for us. Our problem is that we have no acquaintance with the horror of crucifixion. Read in this light, I cannot help be struck by the horrible, eery silence of Jesus during most of Mark's crucifixion narrative (a theme I hope to develop a bit further in a paper I am preparing for the Mark Group at this year's SBL Annual Meeting).
Diese Dezenz geht dem Film von Mel Gibson ab. Er folgt zwar der biblischen Darstellung, aber er ist nicht biblisch.
Second, as I have often commented in the past, the idea that The Passion of the Christ falls short on the atonement is a fallacy. The film strives hard to set Jesus' death as a triumphant eschatological, salvation event in which sin is defeated and Satan is cast into hell (on more of which, see my article in the forthcoming Corley / Webb volume, on which I will be commenting in due course).
BNTC Conference Programme
The British New Testament Conference 2004 Programme is also now available on the web:
BNTC 2004 Conference Programme
BNTC 2004 Conference Programme
Saturday, August 21, 2004
Cave of John the Baptist: James Tabor speaks
In previous posts (Cave of John the Baptist (updated) and More on the John the Baptist Cave), I wondered what James Tabor's views were on this phenomenon given his close involvement with the digs. On Thursday he posted to the ANE List:
[ANE] The Cave of John the Baptist
The archive is publicly available so non-subscribers can read the whole message. Here is one excerpt, but it is all worth consulting:
[ANE] The Cave of John the Baptist
The archive is publicly available so non-subscribers can read the whole message. Here is one excerpt, but it is all worth consulting:
In a sentence, the connection to the 1st century rests on the ceramic evidence, which is in turn connected to ritual activities associated with water purification rites and other ceremonies that were clearly going on in this period. Those who find Gibson's hypothesis weak need to suggest plausible alternatives that take into account such evidence and offer more persuasive explanations related to what was found. The 4th-5th century pilgrim hypothesis misses the mark totally when all is taken into account. It is part of the story, but only one part, in terms of the long history of this cave, its varied use, and its earlier connection to ritual activity.
Also in the Church Times
Also in this week's Church Times a short report on the news item of the week:
Was this John the Baptist’s cave, asks archaeologist
Pat Ashworth
This is mainly worth looking at for its little cartoon ("John the Baptist's Cave: Mind Your Head").
In Book Reviews, it's nice to see a mention for the following work, for which I was one of the authors:
THE GOOD BOOK PACK
By BBC Staff
This is only really a notice, though. It features a link to the purchase details: The Good Book Pack
Finally, there is a review by Mark Edwards of the following:
THE SONG OF SONGS: Interpreted by early Christian and medieval commentators
By Richard A. Norris Jr, editor
Was this John the Baptist’s cave, asks archaeologist
Pat Ashworth
This is mainly worth looking at for its little cartoon ("John the Baptist's Cave: Mind Your Head").
In Book Reviews, it's nice to see a mention for the following work, for which I was one of the authors:
THE GOOD BOOK PACK
By BBC Staff
This is only really a notice, though. It features a link to the purchase details: The Good Book Pack
Finally, there is a review by Mark Edwards of the following:
THE SONG OF SONGS: Interpreted by early Christian and medieval commentators
By Richard A. Norris Jr, editor
. . . And is it really nothing but a love song? The austere modern critic pronounces it impossible that God should be conceived as a man with deer-like nipples, playing hide and seek with his bride-to-be through the streets of Jerusalem; but has there been a society, however “primitive” or “oriental”, in which it was thought flattering for a woman to be told that she had a nose like a tower and hair like a flock of goats?This is in the Eerdmans series The Church's Bible, on which I have commented here before.
Review of Ruth Edwards, Discovering John
| This week's Church Times carries an enthusiastic review of Ruth Edwards's book on the Fourth Gospel:
DISCOVERING JOHN By Ruth Edwards SPCK £14.99 (0-281-05403-7) |
The review is by Richard Burridge and he likes the book:
This sensible yet sensitively written, thoroughly well-read study provides a cautious assessment of the state of play of Johannine scholarship, in a way that is helpful for all who teach and study John today. It is the fruit of a lifetime’s study from Ruth Edwards, a Scottish Episcopalian priest who has taught at Aberdeen and Oxford.The book cover picture above is from Amazon.co.uk, who have it for £10.49 (on a £14.95 cover price). I can't find the book on Amazon.com. This may well be because it does not yet have an American distributor -- SPCK do these on a case-by-case basis, e.g. a forthcoming collection of essays on Q is to be released in North America by IVP. If that is the case, and the book is as good as Burridge says it is, it is a shame.
It is comprehensive in scope, including both historical and literary approaches; it digs around behind the text, but also faces the way in which it is applied to today . . . .
. . . . More than a decade ago, I was a member of the John Seminar at the British New Testament Conference, with Dr Edwards, during the years in which I taught an undergraduate course on John. I wish this text had been available then. It will be of great benefit, not just to students, but also to churches and individual Christians, for which we owe her thanks.
Michael Prior Tributes and Obituaries
I was sorry to read in today's Times of the death of Michael Prior on 21 July 2004:
Father Michael Prior
Roman Catholic priest and scholar who campaigned for the rights of Palestinians
I first met Michael Prior in 2001 when I began external examining at St Mary's College, Strawberry Hill, where he was employed from 1977 until his death. The obituary describes him as "genial and with a lively sense of humour", which is exactly right -- he was a larger than life character, with real warmth. He will be missed.
The St Mary's College web site features a research profile on Michael Prior. It also has an announcement of his death:
Tribute to Fr Michael Prior CM
And The Tablet obituary of 31 July is reproduced on this Vincentian Priests and Brothers site, with some further links too:
FR MICHAEL PRIOR CM
Father Michael Prior
Roman Catholic priest and scholar who campaigned for the rights of Palestinians
FATHER MICHAEL PRIOR was a biblical scholar who spent much of his life writing and campaigning about the rights of the Palestinians in the Holy Land. A radical priest, he was also an outspoken critic of Zionism, which, he argued in his books, articles and lectures, was unbliblical.The obituary mentions several of Michael Prior's publications including The Bible and Colonialism: A Moral Critique. Also worth a mention is Jesus the Liberator: Nazareth Liberation Theology (Luke 4.16-30) (The Biblical Seminar; Sheffield: Sheffield Academic Press, 1995).
I first met Michael Prior in 2001 when I began external examining at St Mary's College, Strawberry Hill, where he was employed from 1977 until his death. The obituary describes him as "genial and with a lively sense of humour", which is exactly right -- he was a larger than life character, with real warmth. He will be missed.
The St Mary's College web site features a research profile on Michael Prior. It also has an announcement of his death:
Professor Michael Prior CMThe Daughters of Charity have carry the following affectionate tribute:
The end of the academic year has been marked by great sadness with the sudden and unexpected death of Professor Michael Prior CM.
Michael Prior was a man of considerable academic distinction, publicly recognised earlier this year through his personal professorship, and a man of strong loyalties and of courage and conviction. He was greatly respected by the students for the personal qualities he brought to his work. He will be greatly missed. The Requiem Mass for Michael Prior was held on Friday 30 July.
Tribute to Fr Michael Prior CM
And The Tablet obituary of 31 July is reproduced on this Vincentian Priests and Brothers site, with some further links too:
FR MICHAEL PRIOR CM
Friday, August 20, 2004
Beliefnet's Best Spiritual Blogs
I picked this up from Dylan's Lectionary Blog:
Best Spiritual Blogs
Beliefnet's picks for the coolest, most interesting faith-based weblogs
I was hoping to discover some new blogs of interest, but alas not, for me at least. But I was delighted to see a mentiion for Jim Davila's Paleojudaica in the list, with the blurb "Weblog about ancient Judaism (yet updated surprisingly often)". Is the implication that one would not expect a blog about ancient Judaism to be updated often? But good to see the honourable mention.
Best Spiritual Blogs
Beliefnet's picks for the coolest, most interesting faith-based weblogs
I was hoping to discover some new blogs of interest, but alas not, for me at least. But I was delighted to see a mentiion for Jim Davila's Paleojudaica in the list, with the blurb "Weblog about ancient Judaism (yet updated surprisingly often)". Is the implication that one would not expect a blog about ancient Judaism to be updated often? But good to see the honourable mention.
Deinde's Biblical Studies Glossary
Deinde have announced the addition of a new Glossary for Biblical Studies terms on their site. Go to:
Biblical Studies Glossary
(You will have to scroll down a little). I am all in favour of this kind of thing -- I cannot count the number of times that students have come to me asking for definitions of terms that their textbooks have taken for granted. I think we should always add a glossary in introductory text books, but I'm in the minority in thinking / executing this. One of the best I am aware of is:
A Basic Vocabulary of Biblical Studies For Beginning Students: A Work in Progress
Fred L. Horton, Jr., Kenneth G. Hoglund, and Mary F. Foskett
Also excellent is:
A Glossary of Important Terms for New Testament Studies
Felix Just, S. J.
I'm afraid that I can't resist putting them to the test on my favourite topic, the Synoptic Problem. How do they perform? Deinde gives the following:
Felix Just, S. J., on the other hand, links to some major explanatory material, both in terms of the problem and proposed solutions. He links to a whole page on The Synoptic Problem and Supposed Solutions, breaking down the problem and offering details of a range of popular solutions, with illustrations.
A Basic Vocabulary site offers the following definition:
Personal bias might lend support to the last of these options, but I would add a very honourable mention to Felix Just, S. J.'s materials, which allow the hyperlinking potential of the web to build up a pretty helpful introductory network of materials for the beginning student.
Let me reiterate that this my experiment with just one of 250 terms in Deinde's excellent Glossary is simply a bit of fun with just that, one out of many terms. I have not yet read all the definitions, but this looks like a useful contribution to the discipline.
Biblical Studies Glossary
(You will have to scroll down a little). I am all in favour of this kind of thing -- I cannot count the number of times that students have come to me asking for definitions of terms that their textbooks have taken for granted. I think we should always add a glossary in introductory text books, but I'm in the minority in thinking / executing this. One of the best I am aware of is:
A Basic Vocabulary of Biblical Studies For Beginning Students: A Work in Progress
Fred L. Horton, Jr., Kenneth G. Hoglund, and Mary F. Foskett
Also excellent is:
A Glossary of Important Terms for New Testament Studies
Felix Just, S. J.
I'm afraid that I can't resist putting them to the test on my favourite topic, the Synoptic Problem. How do they perform? Deinde gives the following:
The question of the relationship between Matthew, The most common, widely held, and probably soundest solution is the 4 source hypothesis that sees Mark as the earliest gospel, with Matthew and Luke each using Mark as a source. Matthew and Luke also used a hypothetical document called 'Q', which explains the verbatim agreements between the two. Matthew and Luke had their own unique material as well (called 'M' and 'L' respectively). So the 4 sources are Mark, Q, M, and L.Something has gone a bit wrong with the first sentence here; presumably, it would have carried on ". . . Mark and Luke". I would personally have preferred to see more by way of definition of the problem than a launching into an alleged "probably soundest" solution too. I would also suggest that it is potentially confusing to talk about "4 source hypothesis" in this context; if one is to speak of the most popular solution, it is the "Two-Source Hypothesis", i.e. Marcan Priority + Q, and this leaves the issue of M and L, in any case unique material, to one side. I also like to see some acknowledgement of other current solutions, perhaps at least Farrer and Griesbach.
Felix Just, S. J., on the other hand, links to some major explanatory material, both in terms of the problem and proposed solutions. He links to a whole page on The Synoptic Problem and Supposed Solutions, breaking down the problem and offering details of a range of popular solutions, with illustrations.
A Basic Vocabulary site offers the following definition:
Addresses the literary relationships among the Gospels of Matthew, Mark and Luke. Currently, the most prominent resolution to the so-called problem is the Two Source theory of Markan priority that posits Mark's Gospel and the Q document as common literary sources that the authors of both Matthew and Luke incorporated into their Gospels. For the latest argument against Q, see Mark Goodacre's "Mark Without Q."This is a good, lean definition, a quick explanation of the dominant solution and a link to an alternative explanation.
Personal bias might lend support to the last of these options, but I would add a very honourable mention to Felix Just, S. J.'s materials, which allow the hyperlinking potential of the web to build up a pretty helpful introductory network of materials for the beginning student.
Let me reiterate that this my experiment with just one of 250 terms in Deinde's excellent Glossary is simply a bit of fun with just that, one out of many terms. I have not yet read all the definitions, but this looks like a useful contribution to the discipline.
RSS feed for Deinde
On my most recent visit to Deinde, I was delighted to see that they now have an RSS feed available. If you have not yet discovered the wonders of reading your blogs via an aggregator, let me recommend it. There are plenty out there. The one I use is Bloglines.
Thursday, August 19, 2004
Another Passion of the Christ Book
| | I have mentioned Robert Webb and Kathleen Corley (eds.), Jesus and Mel Gibson's Passion of the Christ, due out at the end of this month, on several occasions. I am familiar with it because I wrote one of the essays in it. Quite by chance, I noticed a kind of rival book on Amazon the other day, and the book cover, with a link to Amazon, appears to the left. So the cover's less interesting than ours, but what else does it have to offer? No editors are listed; the publisher is Miramax and the full title is Perspectives on the Passion of the Christ: Religious Thinkers and Writers Explore the Issues Raised by the Controversial Movie. |
Here is the blurb:
Since its release on Ash Wednesday 2004, The Passion of the Christ has become a commercial success of astonishing proportions, already ranking as one of the highest grossing films of all time. At the same time, it has created a torrent of controversy and debate, provoking passionate responses — both negative and positive—from people of widely divergent backgrounds and beliefs. It has exposed fundamental differences of opinion and belief about everything from the historical truth of the Bible to the political power of Hollywood.Perhaps the major difference from our volume (and I hope the editors will allow me the use of "our" here, though I need to add that I am only a contributor to the volume; I have not even read the other essays, except for one) is that it features contributions from several of those who were involved with the controversy surrounding the film from the beginning, including several members of the "ad hoc committee". The list of contributors is:
Perspectives on the Passion of the Christ gathers together contributions from theologians, journalists, academics, and philosophers representing a wide spectrum of views and backgrounds. From the film's theological and historical underpinnings, to its cinematic and cultural implications, here is a balanced and thought-provoking exploration of the vital questions raised by The Passion of the Christ. Jews and Christians, evangelicals and agnostics, filmmakers and scholars—the film elicits fascinating responses from all. Among others, Jon Meacham of Newsweek looks hard at the historical record and asks, "Who Really Killed Jesus?" Rev. Susan Thistlethwaite asks why such an exceptionally violent movie has been embraced by so many conservative Christians and argues that The Passion of the Christ presents Jesus as a hero in a war movie; Rabbi Eugene Korn considers the movie's potential impact on interfaith relations; and Steve Martin offers an oblique comic view, from the perspective of a Hollywood insider.
Full of insight into a phenomenon that has raised so many burning and complex issues, this collection is the indispensable guide to understanding the cultural lightning rod that is The Passion of the Christ.
Contributors include: Mary C. Boys, Deborah Caldwell, Philip A. Cunningham, Paula Fredriksen, Lawrence A. Frizzell, Eugene Korn, Linda Kulman, Amy-Jill Levine, James Martin, Steve Martin, Jon Meacham, John T. Pawlikowski, Stephen Prothero, Adele Reinhartz, Susan Brooks Thistlethwaite, Jay Tolson, Jim Wallis, Leon Wieseltier, Ben Witherington IIIOf those, Boys, Cunningham, Fredriksen, Korn and Levine were all members of the ad hoc committee. So the book will clearly have something of a view from the inside of the controversy. The down side of that may be that that the views of all of those authors are all pretty well publicised now; Fredriksen alone has written several articles on the film and the controversy, and Boys recently published an article in Cross Currents on which I still have a half-written response for this blog. Witherington's views are known from the Beliefnet "Scholarly Smackdown", now no longer available for free on the net; his dialogue partner, John Dominic Crossan, on the other hand, contributes to our volume.
More anon when I have received my copy.
Blogwatch: AKMA on John the Baptist's Cave
Make sure you don't miss a delightful post from AKMA on the Shimon Gibson story; a couple of excerpts are included below -- but read it all:
Dear John
Dear John
I think that this sort of story is what helped turn me off archaeology; this, and the weeks of grimy labor sifting sand under the hot sun retrieving nothing but potsherds . . . .
. . . . This story reflects several problematic tendencies in the popular (biblical) archaeological market. We get their textual siblings over in literary historiography, so I’m not casting stones only at the other interpreters. But there have been heaps of hermits (I just spent way too much time trying to devise a collective noun for anchorites) in the Judean wilderness about whom we know absolutely nothing. We happen to know a little about one of them: John. So when an archaeologist finds a hermit’s cave that fits what we might expect John’s cave to have looked like, someone draws the inference that it actually was John’s cave.
The Bible narratives have a power over the imagination that tempts people to lead way beyond what the evidence offers . . . . Given “evidence” over here, and “possible answer” over there, people want badly to connect them and eliminate the uncertainty that dogs inconclusive data. Plus, more people will buy a book or watch a TV special is it says “Cave of John the Baptist” than if it says “Cave of Ascetic With Lustration Pools.”
But that’s a kind of argumentation that we would never accept in other spheres. It’s all circumstantial evidence, no positive evidence (as far as I’ve seen); and though we wouldn’t expect to see a stone at the entrance of the cave saying “937 Hermit Drive, Home of John the Baptist,” we have no particular reason to think that this was John’s own actual cave as opposed to the cave of some other hermit who might have looked like John, or a cave that some post-Johannine Baptists used for memorializing John. “Man with wild hair and carrying a staff”? Must be John the Baptist!
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)