Response to Lüdemann on Lüdemann's homepage

Just before Christmas, some readers will remember that I engaged in a discussion of Gerd Lüdemann's press release The Christmas Stories are Pious Fairy Tales. I responded in Lüdemann on Christmas; then Prof. Lüdemann responded to my blog post in Response to Mark Goodacre and Stephen Carlson and I added a further Response to Lüdemann. The dialogue is also now reproduced on Gerd Lüdedmann's Homepage, and I am grateful to Prof. Lüdemann for giving me this gracious "right to reply".